NCLAT rejects EY partner’s plea in Byju’s-Aakash case | Bengaluru News

Bengaluru: The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) dismissed an appeal filed by Shailendra Ajmera, resolution professional for Think & Learn (Byju’s) and a partner at Ernst & Young (EY), in the ongoing dispute over Aakash Educational Services (AESL).Ajmera challenged an April 30 order by the NCLT Bengaluru that directed all parties to maintain the status quo on Byju’s 25% stake in AESL. The NCLAT held that the order was interim and passed with the consent of all parties, making it ineligible for appeal. The tribunal’s bench, comprising Justice Sharad Kumar Sharma and technical member Jatindranath Swain, sided with arguments presented by senior counsels for AESL and the Manipal Group, which is the largest shareholder in AESL. They said Ajmera’s appeal was not legally maintainable and that the underlying company petition under Sections 241–242 of the Companies Act was itself questionable given the ongoing insolvency proceedings.The appellate bench also noted that the April 30 order stemmed from a prior arrangement recorded by the Karnataka High Court on April 8, following the quashing of an earlier NCLT order that was passed without hearing all stakeholders. The matter will now return to the NCLT Bengaluru for a full hearing. Among the issues to be decided are whether the interim arrangement should continue, whether EY should be made a party to the proceedings due to its advisory role to multiple stakeholders, and whether Ajmera’s petition is maintainable. The dispute follows a series of transactions that led to the Manipal Group acquiring a controlling stake in AESL. Byju’s acquired AESL in 2021 in a deal valued at around $1 billion.