‘Can a dead economy grow at 8.2%?’: FM Sitharaman rebuts Trump remark in Lok Sabha; cites IMF ratings upgrade

Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Monday cited India’s strong growth and sovereign rating upgrades to counter claims that the country was a “dead economy”, telling the Lok Sabha that such upgrades would not have been possible if the economy were weak, PTI reported.Responding to Opposition members who sought the government’s reaction to US President Donald Trump’s description of India as a “dead economy”, Sitharaman said India remains the fastest-growing major economy, recording 8.2% growth in the September quarter.“The economy in the last 10 years has transitioned from external vulnerability to external resilience,” the minister said while replying to the Supplementary Demands for Grants for 2025-26 in the House.“Every institution is raising our growth outlook for this year and the forthcoming year. There are clear expressions (from the IMF) recognising India’s growth and no dead economy gets a credit rating upgrade by DBRS, S&P and R&I,” Sitharaman said.Trump had made the “dead economy” remark in July while expressing disappointment with India’s decision to continue buying oil from Russia. Sitharaman said data and assessments by global institutions contradicted that characterisation.“The economy today has moved from fragility to fortitude,” she said.“So somebody said something somewhere, however important that somebody is, we should not depend on that but rely on data available within the country and also data coming from elsewhere. Rely on data,” she told Opposition members.“Can a dead economy grow at 8.2%? Can a dead economy get credit rating upgrades?” Sitharaman asked.The Reserve Bank of India last week raised its GDP growth projection for FY26 to 7.3% from 6.8% earlier. India grew 8.2% in the September quarter and 7.8% in the June quarter.On concerns raised over the International Monetary Fund’s assessment of India’s national accounts — including Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and Gross Value Added (GVA) — Sitharaman said India’s overall grading remains unchanged at the median rating of ‘B’.She said the IMF had flagged the outdated base year for national accounts and suggested rebasing. “So to say that there has been a downgrade by IMF is misleading the House. For this year, IMF gave B for overall statistics,” she said, adding that India has remained the fastest-growing major economy for the fourth consecutive year despite the pandemic.Sitharaman also addressed concerns over public debt, saying India’s debt-to-GDP ratio rose to 61.4% after Covid but was brought down to 57.1% by 2023-24 due to policy measures taken by the central government.“By this year-end, I expect it to come down to 56.1%,” the finance minister said.